SEO Reporting: An overview of important KPIs including instructions

Imagine investing time, budget, and resources in SEO month after month, but not knowing whether it's worth the effort. What if it's all for nothing? Where should you invest more time and where less? So that you know exactly that and don't just have to rely on your gut feeling, you should also track and analyze your measures and their impact. Otherwise, you won't see any progress, no setbacks, no patterns. And above all: You miss out on the opportunity to improve your measures based on data.

In this article, we therefore not only give you an overview of the most important SEO indicators (KPIs), but also a structured step-by-step guide on how to set up, analyze and implement effective reporting into concrete measures. Including tips from our daily practice as an SEO agency and recommendations for tools that have really proven effective.

Definition: What does SEO reporting mean?

SEO reporting is the structured process in which relevant key figures for search engine optimization (part of online marketing) are regularly collected, analyzed and documented. The reporting itself therefore provides you with a clear overview of the status, development and impact of your optimizations. The aim is to make the success of your SEO work measurable, for yourself, for stakeholders, customers or even for superiors.

However, it is important not to confuse SEO reporting with pure data analysis. Reporting rather means that you collect data, prepare it visually and comprehensibly, and draw conclusions from it. The analysis follows in the next step when you derive concrete optimization measures.

Step-by-step guide for your SEO reports

If you want to know whether your SEO measures are really worthwhile, you need more than just a good gut feeling: You need reliable data. In the following guide, we will therefore show you step by step how to create a professional SEO report, which tools and key figures are important, and how to derive concrete recommendations for action from figures.

Step 0: Carry out a comprehensive SEO analysis if you haven't already done so

Before you even think about creating SEO reports regularly, you need a clean inventory: SEO analysis. It is your strategic starting point and ensures that your website is examined holistically once. Here you are not only looking at what is happening right now, but also systematically evaluating the condition of your entire website.

Anyone who also takes the time for a well-founded analysis not only saves resources later on, but also achieves measurably better results. Why Because targeted measures are always more effective than blanket optimization. And for that, you need a clear picture of the current state of your website.

This step can be broken down into four main areas:

• Technique: Which technical errors are slowing down your site? Here, you look in particular at factors such as crawling errors, incorrect redirects, indexing problems, page speed and mobile usability.
• Content: Is your content prepared in a search engine and user-friendly way? This includes, for example, quality, search intent, keyword coverage, timeliness and internal competition.
• structure: How logical and efficient is the site structure? Important factors here include navigation, URL logic, internal linking and depth-of-click.
• competition: What are your opportunities and risks compared to direct competitors?

We usually also carry out this analysis in extended form when onboarding new customers, as it provides the data basis for a successful SEO strategy and realistic roadmap.

The difference between SEO analysis and SEO reporting

By the way, SEO analysis and SEO reporting are often lumped together, and both serve different purposes. SEO analysis is usually a unique, deep look into the structure, technology and content of your website. The aim is to identify weak points and derive recommendations for action. SEO reporting, on the other hand, is an ongoing process. It measures the impact of your SEO measures over time. The analysis is therefore more strategic, the reporting operational. Ideally, the two are intertwined: The analysis provides the initial situation, the reporting tracks the implementation.

An example: Your SEO analysis shows that your product pages have too little content and therefore rank poorly. The reporting will later show you whether the newly created texts actually improve visibility and whether the rankings are stabilizing.

Step 1: Understand the purpose of your SEO report

An SEO report is not simply a series of figures, it is the strategic backbone of your SEO measures and shows you how your website is doing in the area of search engine optimization. In practice, however, we often see that companies collect data but do not gain any clear insights from it. This is exactly where a professional SEO report comes in: It combines figures with context and shows what happened, why it happened and what needs to be done next.

It is therefore not just about rankings, a good SEO report also analyses visibility, user behavior, technical aspects, content quality and much more and thus tells a story — of goals, developments, successes and challenges.

The focus is always on answers to the questions:

• What measures were carried out?
• What has changed?
• How does this affect your goals?
• Is your organic traffic growing?
• Is your content easier to find?
• Are you increasing the conversion rate?

For companies, teams or agencies like us at SEO Galaxy, the SEO report is also an important means of communication. It transparently shows the customer which steps have been taken, which successes have already been achieved and where there is still potential. Or gives you, as an employee, the necessary arguments for budgets, resources and necessary strategic adjustments.

What does an SEO report need to include in addition to KPIs?

Elements such as the following may also be important:

• Top landing pages: Which sites perform particularly well?
• Technical analysis: Are there indexing issues, incorrect redirects, or load time issues?
• Backlink profile: How is your domain authority developing?
• Conversions and goals: Which actions lead to leads, sales, or other conversions?

Depending on your goals, you can of course also expand or focus on these areas. For example, the conversion rate for organic traffic is particularly important for online shops, while content pages focus more on visibility and interaction rate.

How often should you do SEO reporting?

Whether you report on a weekly, monthly or quarterly basis plays a rather minor role, but the frequency should match the size of the company and the complexity of your measures. We usually recommend to our customers

• monthly SEO reports for continuous monitoring and management.
• Quarterly summaries for budget discussions or strategy adjustments.
• annual deep dives, which also take into account market changes, technical developments or new objectives.

However, for larger websites or in particularly dynamic markets (e.g. online shops with thousands of products), it can be useful to create weekly reports for greater clarity. However, these should then be automated more so as not to unnecessarily burden the team. So here's another tip from practice: It's best to work with a standardized template from the start. This not only makes it easier to create, but also makes it easier to compare over time. Before/after graphics and your own comments on developments and their impact on SEO and general business goals are also particularly helpful instead of mere jumps of numbers!

Step 2: Set the most important KPIs for your SEO reports

A common mistake that we see, especially among beginners: Too many KPIs (Key Performance Indicator” or “Performance Indicator”) are collected in SEO reports and that without clear prioritization. However, a good SEO report is not about mass, but about relevance. Anything else only leads to unclear reports, overwhelming demands and ultimately inactivity. So it's no use overloading your SEO report with 30 KPIs if no one understands what's important in the end. So you'd better focus on the metrics that are directly linked to your goals.

Which KPIs belong in every SEO report?

The exact SEO KPIs that your report should include depend primarily on who you are preparing it for. For example, management is usually only interested in whether visibility increases, leads are coming and SEO contributes to sales. For an SEO manager, on the other hand, technical KPIs, on-page data or backlink quality also count. The better you prepare your reporting, the better you can convince and initiate well-founded decisions.

The most important metrics that we also regularly evaluate at SEO Galaxy include:

• Organic traffic: How many visitors come from organic search and where exactly? Pay particular attention to developments over time, seasonal influences and new start pages.
• Keyword rankings: How are your main and secondary keywords developing? In addition to positions, you should also pay attention to visibility trends and competition density.
• Visibility index: How visible is your domain compared to competitors? This is a good overall indicator of your SEO strength in a competitive environment.
• Click-through rate (CTR): How often does your site actually get clicked on in search results? This gives you clues as to whether your snippets are appealing. For example, if you are in position 1-3 but your CTR is below < 2%, you can usually get even more out of it.
• Bounce rate & length of stay: How often do users leave your site without interaction? This allows you to see whether your content really matches the search intent.
• Conversion rate: How many users perform a desired action? How many of them become customers? One of the most important metrics when it comes to leads, sales, or other defined goals.
• Core Web Vitals: How good is the technical performance of your website? This is because Google is also actively evaluating this, which primarily influences rankings in mobile playback.

Each of these key figures highlights a different aspect of your SEO performance and only in combination does a clear overall picture emerge, which serves as a solid basis for your next optimization steps. For comprehensive reporting, you can use tools such as Google Search Console, Google Analytics or Matomo. These are ideal for beginners and (to a large extent) free of charge. For experts, accounts with Sistrix, SEMrush, Ahrefs or Ryte offer extended functions and deeper analyses.

Step 3: Derive measures from the SEO report

The most common mistake in everyday SEO? Collect data and then... nothing. However, professional reporting and clean analysis only serve their purpose if clear, implementable measures are derived from them (this is exactly where strategic SEO separates from pure monitoring). A good SEO report should therefore enable you to take targeted action based on the observed developments. That's why you proceed in step 3:

Identify patterns and analyze causes

Start with a look at the big picture: Are there recurring patterns or outliers in your key figures? Examples from practice:

• For example, do blog articles continuously lose visibility while category pages remain stable?
• Is organic traffic increasing but the conversion rate falling in parallel?
• Do certain types of pages have particularly high bounce rates or load times?
• Are there a lot of impressions but hardly any clicks, which is reflected in a low CTR?

Try as best as possible to link the metrics together in order to derive initial measures more easily. That could then look like this:

Low CR from search results + low CTR = potential through snippet optimization.

High traffic + high bounce rate = maybe the content doesn't match the search intent.

Step 4: Assign specific goals & tracking options to your measures

Each measure or combination of strategic measures should also pursue a specific goal, which can be measured on its own. This is the only way you can evaluate in the next SEO report whether the effort was worthwhile. Let's take the website of a craftsman company as an example. The goal: The Improve the ranking of a blog article from position 12 to position <5.

Possible measures:

• Update content (new paragraphs, fresh sources, updated information)
• Revise H2 structure and snippets (better readability, strengthen keyword focus)
• Increase internal links to this page from thematically relevant articles
• Include images with alt text and structured data (FAQ, HowTo)

Possible measurement:

• Follow ranking development, e.g. via Sistrix, SEMrush or Ahrefs (before/after comparison after 2, 4, 6 weeks)
• Evaluate click rate (CTR) via Google Search Console
• Organic clicks and their increase compared to the previous period
• Time spent and scrolling depth to see whether users are really “using” the content

Through SEO reporting, you set a sudden loss of ranking on one of your top landing pages fixed? Then your goal would most likely be to find and fix the causes of the loss of ranking on the revenue-relevant site

Possible measures:

• Perform a technical SEO audit using Screaming Frog or Sitebulb (e.g. canonicals, indexing issues, Robots.txt)
• Analyze backlink profile (removal of strong links?)
• Check for changes in search intent or SERP features
• Revise content and supplement it with up-to-date information
• Restoring or strengthening an internal link to the page

Possible measurement:

• Comparing rankings before and after implementation
• Review of click and impression trends in GSC
• Visibility development of the affected URL
• Restoring conversion figures (if affected)

On the other hand, if the goal was to reduce the bounce rate of the homepage, measures such as new CTAs or an optimized above-the-fold section can help, while KPIs such as length of stay and bounce rate before and after the adjustment tell you more about the success of your measures.

Step 5: Prioritize measures

Not every finding from the report requires immediate action. Therefore: Focus on impact. For every potential task, ask yourself:

• How big is the impact on my SEO goals (e.g. visibility, conversions, load time)?
• How complex is the implementation (time, resources, technology)?

This results in a clear structure:

Quick Wins: High-impact tasks with little effort. These include measures such as optimizing title & meta descriptions, increasing internal linking to stronger pages, adding missing alt texts, improving snippets for higher CTR and adding structured data (Schema.org).

Medium-term measures/SEO strategies: Things that need a bit of preparation but can also have a strong impact. These include measures such as revising poorly performing blog articles, resolving keyword cannibalization, improving mobile optimization and stabilizing Core Web Vitals.

Long-term projects: These measures require more resources, but contribute sustainably to SEO success. This includes creating complete content hubs, relaunching the site structure, building a backlink strategy and internationalization, e.g. introducing new language versions.

For this step, we recommend an SEO action board, in which you can classify all identified tasks according to impact, urgency and resource expenditure. This allows you to keep focus even with dozens of options for action, which also makes it easier for you to evaluate.

Step 6: Structure your first SEO report

A successful SEO report does not follow a rigid pattern, but, as already mentioned, is based on your business goals, your target group and the agreed tasks. However, there is a basic structure that has proven effective in practice and is easy to understand both for internal teams and external customers:

1. Overview and Objectives: Start the report with a short executive summary: What was the goal of the month? Which measures have been implemented? What were the challenges?

2. Performance analysis (SEO metrics): Here are the hard facts: visibility, keyword rankings, organic traffic and technical indicators, supplemented by helpful visualizations. We also recommend highlighting different KPIs depending on the target group. Perhaps the conversion rate for management, but rather indexing status and backlink growth for the SEO team.

3. Overview of measures: At this point, show exactly what has been done in the past period. A structure according to OnPage, OffPage and technical SEO can be useful.

4. Recommendations for action: A good SEO report never just ends with figures, but offers concrete next steps. What are the next tasks? What potential was identified?

In the best case scenario, this structure allows your readers to get a clear overview in the form of a type of report in just a few minutes, a maximum of 10-15 minutes of reading time, and know directly what it's about.

Step 7 (optional): Create an actionable roadmap

Now it's time to implement it. If you also want to take on this role yourself or are responsible for it in your team, it is now time to create a realistic schedule with the prioritized tasks that involves all parties involved (e.g. editorial, IT, product team). That includes:

• What is being implemented? (e.g. optimize 20 snippets, revise 3 landing pages)
• Why is it relevant? (e.g. low CTR, ranking potential on page 2)
• Who is responsible? (e.g. SEO, copywriting, dev team)
• By when should it happen? (e.g. next two weeks)

In this step, tools such as Trello, Asana or Notion also help you move directly from the report to the task distribution and make progress in various areas visible.

SEO monitoring: Identify developments before they become a problem

Monitoring takes place before and after reporting, which basically means nothing more than continuous monitoring, comparison and then optimization (after the report has been created). You can think of good SEO monitoring as an early warning system: It signals to you in good time when changes are imminent, whether positive or negative. You can therefore follow current developments, but also recognize patterns that influence your success in the long term.

However, you need the right SEO tools to implement it. We have therefore put together a selection of proven monitoring tools for you, which we also regularly use in our agency:

• Google Search Console: Essential for technical reports, indexing status, searches, and impressions.
• Google Analytics 4: For deeper insights into user behavior, length of stay and conversion rate.
• Sistrix & SEMrush: Ideal for daily keyword rankings, competitive analysis, and visibility developments.
• UptimeRobot & PageSpeed Tools: To check load times and availability, two factors that Google is increasingly evaluating.

With these tools, organic website traffic in particular can be monitored almost completely. The combination of data sources is also particularly valuable, as this gives you a valid database that you can use for strategic decisions.

The best way to do this is to create automated dashboards with Google Data Studio or Looker Studio. Here, the most important KPIs from various tools can be automatically combined, visualized and provided with thresholds. This not only allows you to recognize changes faster, but also allows you to communicate them transparently and based on data within the team.

Automate your reporting largely & react promptly to changes

SEO is dynamic and time delays can therefore be expensive in the truest sense of the word. Sudden ranking losses, incorrect referrals or outages happen, but it is important to react as early as possible. Fortunately, you can also use automated alerts to be informed immediately. For example with

• Ranking losses for top keywords
• Traffic declines on important sites
• Technical errors, such as high 404 rates or sudden indexing issues

In our work as an SEO agency, we also systematically set up these alerts via SEMrush, Ahrefs, GSC or uptime services such as UptimeRobot. For example, if there are problems with server availability or page load times, we receive a message within a few minutes and can act immediately before rankings or leads are lost.

Conclusion: SEO reporting is just the start

Good SEO reporting is much more than a mandatory monthly task. It shows you whether you are on the right track, whether your measures are taking effect and where improvements are needed. But above all, it gives you security: You know what works, what doesn't and what to do next. But to do that, you have to do more than just collect numbers. Only if you correctly select your KPIs, put them in the right context and derive clear recommendations for action from them, will SEO reporting become a real growth strategy. Whether it's to increase organic traffic, improve rankings, or achieve conversion goals, the data shows you the way.

That's why our advice from practice:

• Always think of reporting with the goal and target group in mind.
• Work with standardized structures and dashboards.
• Automate where it makes sense, but always analyze with a clear head.
• And above all: Use your reports afterwards as a basis for concrete optimizations, because in the end, it is not the prettiest Excel spreadsheet that is decisive, but what you make of it.

FAQ: Frequently asked questions about SEO Reporting

Below you will find the most important answers to the most common questions about SEO reporting.

What is the difference between SEO reporting and SEO analysis?

SEO reporting regularly documents the development of important key figures, such as visibility or traffic. An SEO analysis, on the other hand, is a unique, deep insight into technology, structure and content in order to identify weak points. Both complement each other and should be combined.

Which KPIs are particularly important for SEO reports?

Key metrics include organic traffic, keyword rankings, visibility index, CTR, length of stay, bounce rate, conversion rate, and core web vitals. However, the selection always depends on your goals and target groups.

How often should an SEO report be created?

A monthly report is useful for most companies, supplemented by quarterly strategy evaluations and deeper analyses every year. For dynamic sites or shops, weekly reporting with automation can also be useful.

Which tools are suitable for professional SEO reporting?

Key tools include Google Search Console, Google Analytics 4, Sistrix, SEMrush, Ahrefs, Ryte, and dashboards in Google Looker Studio. They provide a comprehensive and visual presentation of the most important metrics.

What do I do with the data after reporting?

Reporting provides you with the basis for measures. Identify patterns, analyze causes and take concrete steps, such as content optimization, technical adjustments, or link building. Reporting only brings real added value if you take action from the figures.

‍